The Triple Burden: Race, Neurodivergence, and Birth Order
Mixed-Race Identity Challenges:
Generally, multiracial groups tended to have worse mental health than other racial groups. Discrimination and ethno-racial identity predicted mental health
[Welldoing](https://welldoing.org/article/whats-the-relationship-neurodiveristy-trauma) .
Mixed-race people make up only two percent of the UK population, making it natural to feel an urge to assimilate just to fit into local communities, often exposing them to years of racially-charged questions, suppressed microaggressions and triggering racism [3SC](https://3sc.org/a-critical-analysis-of-current-research-on-trauma-and-neurodiversity-arguments-and-counter-arguments/) .
Multiracial individuals experience racial identity invalidation, which involves others denying a multiracial individual’s racial identity or imposing an identity with which the multiracial person does not identify, and familial discrimination, which refers to problematic behaviours perpetrated by one’s family members, such as stereotyping [Khiron Clinics](https://khironclinics.com/blog/trauma-and-neurodiversity/) .
Multiracial people sometimes describe their experiences of leading a double life (one race or culture at home and another at school or work), code-switching (shifting how you talk, present yourself, or act around different groups of people), struggling with identity conflicts within a polarized culture, and facing microaggressions at every turn [LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/neurodiversity-101-navigating-intersection-trauma-prof-amanda-kirby-ahoke) .
The “What Are You?” Experience:
Multiracial individuals are often considered “half” or “watered down” versions of their identities, and can feel excluded from their communities, experiencing being “too much” of something or “not enough” [Kelly Mahler](https://www.kelly-mahler.com/resources/blog/unsafe-unheard-misunderstood-trauma-neurodiversity/) . One idiosyncratic part of the multiracial experience is that individuals are sometimes asked “What are you?” regarding their identity [Cornerstones of Care](https://www.cornerstonesofcare.org/beyond-labels-embracing-neurodiversity-through-a-trauma-informed-lens/) .
Neurodivergence and Trauma Connection
People with Autistic Spectrum Disorder are three times as likely to be exposed to trauma and 80% of adults with ADHD report trauma experiences. Being neurodivergent makes it four times as likely for PTSD to develop [Welldoing](https://welldoing.org/article/whats-the-relationship-neurodiveristy-trauma) .
The Masking Cycle:
Many neurodivergent girls learn to mask their differences, using strong verbal skills to fit in. This pressure to conform leads to emotional exhaustion, anxiety, and depression. The lived experience of navigating a neurotypical world itself can constitute trauma, particularly when misunderstood or invalidated. This creates a self-perpetuating trauma cycle: repeated negative experiences create internalized shame, leading to masking behaviors, then hypervigilance, and ultimately burnout.
Chinese Cultural Expectations: Filial Piety and Gender Roles
Filial Piety (孝 – Xiào):
Filial piety is a central theme in Asian culture and is seen as care for one’s parents as part of a traditional concept of Confucianism. Older people may hold strong expectations for filial piety from their children [Fevers of the Mind](https://feversofthemind.com/2023/11/02/a-fevers-of-the-mind-book-review-eldest-daughter-a-break-up-story-by-megan-cannella-reviewed-by-sara-dobbie/) .
Filial piety is defined as respect for one’s parents, elders, and ancestors, rooted in a commitment to maintaining a hierarchical power structure within families. Children are expected to pay deep reverence to their elders and parents, and rather than creating open lines of communication, children are told to obey their parents at all times, it’s a sign of respect [Breeze](https://breeze-wellbeing.com/blog/eldest-daughter-syndrome/) .
Authoritative filial piety focuses on pushing away the individuality of a child, such that one’s actions of honor and respect are done out of obedience to the norms and roles, focusing on submission and compliance, with a stronger focus on family hierarchy where seniority is pivotal [Birthtraumaassociation](https://www.birthtraumaassociation.org/news-campaigns/blog-post-title-four-4jwnw-x3zm9-he23x-4gycw-zr29a-8nx7j-ww4mj) .
Gender-Specific Pressures:
In traditional Asian families, each individual has a clearly defined role and position in the family hierarchy determined by age, gender, and social class. Female children have a lower status than male children within the family. In Chinese culture, the wife is expected to become part of her husband’s family. The mother’s job is to nurture and care for her husband and children [Bay Area CBT Center](https://bayareacbtcenter.com/eldest-daughter-syndrome/) .
Emotional Suppression:
In Asian cultures, women stated that speaking openly about their feelings, especially in public, was frowned upon. The notion of seeking help from a source outside the family was regarded as not conforming to Asian cultural values and counter to family expectations. Given the importance of the family unit, perceived shame and stigma naturally extended beyond the service user to their families and had the potential to impact on family honor or reputation [Zencare](https://blog.zencare.co/eldest-daughter-syndrome-mental-health/) [Chrysaliswellnesswnc](https://chrysaliswellnesswnc.com) .
In many Asian households, children are expected to control or hide their emotions to prevent being perceived as someone who complains too much. This can translate to family environments where silence is a sign of strength and feelings aren’t likely shared [Breeze](https://breeze-wellbeing.com/blog/eldest-daughter-syndrome/) .
The Eldest Daughter Experience
Cultural Amplification:
For a mixed-race White-Chinese eldest daughter, the expectations are compounded. From the Chinese side: filial piety demands obedience, emotional suppression, caregiving responsibilities, and sacrifice of personal needs. From the British side: expectations for independence and self-expression create internal conflict. As the eldest daughter, there’s pressure to be the cultural mediator, translator of values between generations, and role model for younger siblings.
Parentification:
The eldest daughter often takes on caregiver or mediator roles to maintain family stability, learning to equate their value with how well they support or care for others. This “parentification” means taking on parental responsibilities from childhood, leading to a stolen childhood and not being able to “act their age.”
Mental Health Impact:
Many first-born daughters become chronic people-pleasers, perfectionists, passive communicators and are at risk of developing anxiety, depression, and sometimes PTSD. Questions such as whether or not one has any say in life or whether the choice to honor parents are of one’s own volition continue to create uncertainty and confusion as individuals struggle to honor their families while striving for independence [Birthtraumaassociation](https://www.birthtraumaassociation.org/news-campaigns/blog-post-title-four-4jwnw-x3zm9-he23x-4gycw-zr29a-8nx7j-ww4mj) .
The Unique UK Context
Mental Health Service Barriers:
The UK mental health system was perceived to be designed for people from white British backgrounds and experienced as meaningless, oppressive, and outdated. This related to the perceived reduction of individuals to labels and symptoms and exclusion of social, racial, religious, and other cultural aspects of illness and person during clinical assessment and treatment [MadameNoire](https://madamenoire.com/1428921/black-mothers-neurodivergent-children/) [Do-IT Profiler](https://doitprofiler.com/insight/navigating-the-intersection-of-trauma-and-neurodiversity/) .
Service users experienced help-seeking as bringing them into conflict with their needs, expectations and values, which negatively impacted on their sense of self, describing experiences of feeling disempowered and dehumanised when accessing services [Chrysaliswellnesswnc](https://chrysaliswellnesswnc.com) .
Cultural Code-Switching:
Growing up in the UK as a mixed-race Chinese person means navigating between British individualism and Chinese collectivism, between expressing emotions freely and suppressing them for family harmony, between pursuing personal goals and fulfilling family obligations.
The Compounded Experience
For a neurodivergent, mixed-race White-Chinese eldest daughter in the UK, the challenges multiply:
1. Identity Confusion: Not feeling “Chinese enough” or “White enough,” while simultaneously navigating neurodivergent traits that make you feel different from everyone
2. Triple Masking: Masking neurodivergent traits, masking cultural identity depending on context, and masking emotions to fulfill filial piety expectations
3. Diagnostic Invisibility: Neurodivergent traits often missed in girls due to masking; cultural expectations prevent seeking help; mixed-race experiences overlooked in predominantly white or monoracial frameworks
4. Eldest Daughter Burden:Expected to excel academically (model minority myth), translate between cultures, care for family members, suppress needs, and maintain family honor—all while managing sensory sensitivities and executive functioning challenges
5. Conflicting Values: Western therapy emphasizes self-expression and boundary-setting; Chinese culture emphasizes duty and family; navigating both while neurodivergent creates profound internal conflict
Path to Healing
Culturally-Informed, Neurodiversity-Affirming Support:
Healing requires therapists who understand the intersection of mixed-race identity, Chinese cultural values, neurodivergence, and eldest daughter dynamics. Finding language and a body of research to validate experiences of identity confusion and internalized racism affirms that feelings are not “all in your head” [Loveontheautismspectrum](https://www.loveontheautismspectrum.com/my-partner-is-neurodiverse-2/) .
Key Approaches:
– Recognize all parts of identity without forcing choice or hierarchy
– Understand filial piety without pathologizing cultural values while also acknowledging when they cause harm
– Create space for grief over lost childhood and unmet needs
– Support boundary-setting without shame, recognizing it may conflict with cultural expectations
– Validate the exhaustion of multiple forms of masking
– Build community with others who share similar intersectional experiences
– Process trauma through a lens that understands both neurodivergence and cultural context
The goal isn’t to choose between identities or reject cultural heritage, but to integrate all parts of oneself—the Chinese and White, the neurodivergent traits, the eldest daughter role, while establishing healthy boundaries and self-compassion.
Leave a comment